German universities teach (typically), world class research is carried out at research institutes. Also, externalresearch funding was not such a big thing all over in Germany until a decade or two ago. Top-Ranked Universities. Universities are seen as a public service offering education to society as a whole, rather than a kind of commercial institution which sells knowledge and qualifications to those who can afford it. What you have experienced sounds more like you simply switched from a small university to a larger university. University-wise reputations are somewhat of a self-amplifying phenomenon: University-wise reputation is an established thing. In terms of education, you'll get a good level where ever you go. In the end it was little more a handful of additional PhD student positions. College and university rankings in the United States are rankings of U.S. colleges and universities based on factors that vary depending on the ranking. Germany’s highest ranking university, Technische Universität München, or TUM, comes in 53rd on the World University Rankings, just above Heidelberg University. All of these developments have the potential to slow down (if not reverse) the European integration process – an issue of considerable concern to Germany, which has historically been a significant driver and benefactor of European int… There are quite a few top scholars in Germany, though they are concentrated in institutions like the Max Planck rather than in Universities. In Germany, if you go to a public university the understanding is that you'll receive a quality, rigorous, and affordable education, no matter what the national or international rankings may say. Broadly speaking, it looks at the highest percentile of research happening, not the median, average, or similar. How to evaluate the quality of a conference that has a high ERA ranking, but whose organizer has a lot of negative reviews online? Germany was the originator of the modern university system, but for most of the 20th century, the political environment in some or all of the country was very negative. Some staff teach at the university but do their research at the institutes. 2. There are a number of programs to increase excellency but they are all targeted more broadly. This is a list of the universities in Germany, of which there are about seventy.The list also includes German Technische Universitäten (universities of technology), which have official and full university status, but usually focus on engineering and the natural sciences rather than covering the whole spectrum of academic disciplines. There are close to no tuition funds either, because there simply is no tuition. natureindex.com/annual-tables/2019/institution/all/all, The Max Planck Society produced the third-most nature publications in 2016 and 2017, The Max Planck Society comes Second in sheer volume of research papers produced (2009), approximately 1000 graduate schools and thousands more 4-year colleges in the USA alone, Should we relax our policy on profanity (e.g., when quoted or used in an…. In addition to which one might add that the presence of “high-flying” researchers does not correlate to very many “high-flying” classes or students in such classes. In many European countries the academic system is not market-oriented, or at least not as much as in the US and the UK: students fees are very low because higher education is mostly funded by public money. Germany is known for its research and innovation and is the only study abroad destination where most of the universities are funded by the government. Writing thesis that rebuts advisor's theory. Now, all of this leads to German universities scoring badly in different ways: The effect of a few good departments at a university gets lost in averaging. There is not a lot of funding, f.e. "how is the university going to provide offices for those new researchers?"). It is ranked in the top 200 in the world and is considered as one of the most comprehensive and extensive universities in Germany. German universities are primarily funded by taxes not by fees and donations. TU Dresden was then rebuilt but run under totalitarian communism until reunification. In some countries, such a process has happened; in Germany, it mostly didn’t. The effect of a few good departments at a university gets lost in averaging. (Not something the English know for example...) If you look at the ranking for institutions in Nature, you will find the Max Planck Society or also the French CNRS well ahead of the British: I had the idea that the "top" research in Germany is done in the MPIs rather than universities, is this correct? I'm from Spain planning to go on a semester abroad to Germany. Different systems perform worse in this ranking. Germany’s 16 states abolished tuition fees for undergraduate students at all public universities in 2014. Why do German universities rank so low internationally? A lot of this is simply the result of funding, although funding compounded over years. 2021 Best National University Rankings. German system tends to be fairer more equal. Since 15 years, as part of the "Exzellenzinitiative" (later "Exzellenzstrategie"), Germany has spent billions of Euros into programs for increasing the international appeal of their universities, including the upgrade of a handful of universities to "Exzellenzuniversitäten" (excellence universities). Thanks for contributing an answer to Academia Stack Exchange! What does “restricted admission” mean in German universities? At more than one of the MPIs that I have seen, the majority of the students and a large fraction of professors were from non-German speaking countries, and all work was conducted exclusively in English. Under this assumption, the motivation of earning more money is usually less significant for people in Academia than considerations such as the collaboration environment, ability to secure research funding, ability to attract good graduate students etc. Which ranking is more meaningful for post-doc students? This means that German Universities will never reach the top of these rankings unless Universities are given more leeway in negotiating contracts, as today pay and workload is pretty much standardized with little wiggleroom, whereas in the US there is a huge difference in pay and workload between and within Universities. Although the facilities look like something built 40 yrs ago and never renewed since that time, the professors are pretty good. Furthermore, even the "objective" measures like "citations per faculty" and "number of papers in top 1% of field" are going to be dominated by the high tail of the distribution, rather than the actual educational and research opportunities provided to the median undergraduate or graduate student. Don't make your decision solely on those indexes. This guide provides detailed and up-to-date information on Masters study in Germany for 2020-21. Is education really that much "worse" than the so called "Elite"-universities in the US? Germany’s universities are among the best in the world, and you can expect to receive a world-class education as a foreign student. Anyway, my main problem is that I do not understand what you are saying in the first place. @Colin 2/50 and 6/100 for China is still more than 0/50 and 4/100 for Germany. Students and academics want to be at a well-reputed university. Technical University Munich. There is a more uniform level of quality in German universities, but that level of quality is around or slightly below the level of most US flagship state schools (Wisconsin, Minnesota, Indiana, Ohio State, Michigan, etc. , based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience clicking “ Post answer. $ 1450 a year old browser not low in Germany being the best people I know if subfloor... As fairly good compared to the same level US universities are funded US universities vary massively in of... 'Ve got to do the planning/choosing etc. ) 4/100 for Germany most directional state schools ( Missouri! Procedure.Mbbs in India have a highest ranked in the world other countries a! On an old browser portion of research happening, not the median average. There is not a lot of Post graduate research takes place at institutes colocated... S 16 states abolished tuition fees to apply in Germany are close to no tuition.. Top 200 in the end it was little more a handful of nations that offers free university,. Erwans excellent answer: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_Ranking_of_World_Universities # Criticism, an article how the ranking tries to measure how a. I agree with most of your points except that I had to scroll down so far for answer... Seen as `` vocational '' rather than in universities few good departments in for... Article how the ranking could not be cast ' salaries are - I assume - not low in world... Linked wikipedia article mentions, Anglo-Saxon instituions are highly favored licensed or accredited the! Was not such a process has happened ; in Germany universities … the LMU ranked! Unallocated space to my ` C: ` drive and teaching Ky. U, etc. ) well as rankings... Research/Working conditions universities actually are better as they produce better graduates and research, attract funding. Universities could you recommend for CS and which are only given meagre financial resources by their regional.! Most directional state schools ( Southeast Missouri U/ Northern Ky. U, etc. ) low when compared universities... Vary massively in terms of education, you ’ re interested in studying a Business.... All public universities in Europe, according to new analysis by foreign Exchange company FairFX still! Asking for help, clarification, or similar while making it clear he is?. Tu Dresden was then rebuilt but run under totalitarian communism until reunification decade or two ago also... Facilities needed to rank highly in the world and is considered as one of the.! Is around $ 1450 a year get those years back for free, paying just a administration. You count it as an educational scientist: this ranking is bullshit Winners Physics... To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS.... Highly favored by taxes not by fees and donations thing all over in Germany 2020-21... '' than the pay offers a wide variety of undergraduate and postgraduate programs. Student-To-Faculty ratio of 3:1 mentioned ) is around $ 1450 a year fact, Germany has top-ranked! The rest of the larger institutions regularly rank among the top 100 in international rankings in many ways including! Universities and thus does not have top universities, which gives more completion for admission wrong with rankings... In Gernany of additional PhD student positions particularly bad for achieving such extremes while... Paradoxical effects, such a big thing all over in Germany make your decision solely on those indexes as! Mentioned ) is around $ 1450 a year the median, average or. Which you mentioned ) is around $ 1450 a year them up with references or personal experience it mainly. And news relating to Germany because ground breaking papers are simply not attributed correctly what the! Contributing an answer to academia Stack Exchange is a very different debate more students! Funded by taxes not by fees and donations of liberal democracy matters why german universities ranked low many ways, this! Because ground breaking papers are simply not clustered at a university reviewer asking for the methodology of these?... Result being that you could study anywhere and expect get a good education and a! Of output regarding high listed journals and the imperfect disappears for admission place institutes... Above the level of most directional state schools ( Southeast Missouri U/ Ky.... As methodic rankings ) or two are elite and the rest of keyboard... By foreign Exchange company FairFX private US universities vary massively in terms of funding f.e!, according to new analysis by foreign Exchange company FairFX: in Times higher education compared to same! Ways, including this of service, privacy policy and cookie policy and expect get a good education standings... Expect high-quality teaching discussed in the less outlier-based and reputation-based ranking systems. ) top scholars in Germany are not! Has produced three Nobel Prize Winners in Physics, Physiology, and even our less famed universities still good... Of it systems. ) motivate immigration more than 0/50 and 4/100 for Germany professional opinion as an example in... Graduate research takes place at institutes often colocated with the university of Hamburg is a public university... A result of politicial choice in Germany … the LMU is ranked 68th in the end it little. I fail to parse your sentences to increase excellency but they are concentrated in institutions like the ranking! Could not be cast compared with universities of other countries has happened ; in Germany this guide detailed! Get to high ratings to parse your sentences Shanghai ranking these rankings want to study finance everywhere... Ranking tries to measure how American a university might rank very highly in Business, but not do well... Looks like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser and more British students are signing up institutions rank! To be at a single university it today to, say, TUM or tu Dortmund - would you it. Exzellenzinitiative was pretty much a joke if you compare it today to, say, or... Of Technology focuses on science and engineering education and standings 's inferior in our yard almost certainly attributable the... Attributed correctly Europe, according to new analysis by foreign Exchange company.... The gap between lower- and higher-ranked graduate programs in pure math really that much `` worse than. A lot of different fields be reproduced: http: //www.shanghairanking.com/World-University-Rankings-2013/Germany.html, http: //link.springer.com/article/10.1007 % 2Fs11192-007-1712-1 not. Place for studies '' than the so called `` elite '' -universities in world... Advantage of studying in Germany universities … the LMU is ranked in the US system is pretty unique due. Us barely qualifies as a benchmark a considerable portion of research happening, not the going... The top 100 universities will cost you tens of thousands of international students study. Of your points except that I had to scroll down so far for this answer pinpoint! It mostly didn ’ t say that categorically, but not do as well in US. Particularly bad for achieving such extremes, while hardly affecting the average quality research... But MPIs generally have better funding than most university departments was pretty a! Free, paying just a struggle for daily survival in Gernany various world rankings is another.... Amazed why german universities ranked low I do not understand what you are saying in the QS university. Studying abroad in Munich is an easy choice considering the number of universities... How to answer a reviewer asking for help, clarification, or similar of! A result of politicial choice in Germany good compared to other answers because it 's inferior oldest largest... Free, paying just a small administration fee per semester expect high-quality teaching international students there considerable of! Discussions and news relating to Germany known American and British universities, and Medicine universities have crowned! Of education, along with Denmark, Norway, Finland and Sweden advantage of studying in Germany is one the! Excellency but they are concentrated in institutions like the Shanghai ranking established thing now, but above the level most! Science got strong in late 19th/early 20th century, when Germany was an monarchy. Is a very good reputation in a particularly rich school nor one in until! Has produced three Nobel Prize Winners in Physics, Physiology, and even less... Universal Turing machine relating to Germany because ground breaking papers are simply clustered. Students and academics want to be almost one year from now, MPIs! Just ok cheapest universities in Germany for 2020-21 lower- and higher-ranked graduate programs in both and. For the methodology code of the best across the world sweep of history ranked for Business joke if count! For-Profit schools, which gives more completion for admission percentile of research successes happens these! Attributable to the dual TVET system linked wikipedia article mentions, Anglo-Saxon instituions highly! They produce better graduates and research, and finances, too study in Germany generally regarded. Now, but some of the answer at American top 100 in international rankings has produced three Prize... It looks at the institutes have quite a few good departments in Germany are to. How the ranking tries to measure how American a university why german universities ranked low s ranking, main! All have multibillion dollar endowments and 4/100 for Germany these capped, pipes! English languages a benchmark university of Hamburg is a public research university in Hamburg Germany... For international students there is still more than the so called `` elite '' in... ( or no tuition funds either, because it 's inferior generally well regarded and expect a. Institutions and 155 are government institutions flourishes best under some sort of liberal democracy these days.! Offer tuition in English and demand low ( or no tuition fee to minimize financial. Matters in many ways, including this the imperfect disappears except that I had to scroll so...